Back To The Old House: Will The Smiths Ever Reform?

The combination of Morrissey’s intense, literary lyricism and guitarist Johnny Marr’s out and out virtuosity, meant 80’s indie forebears The Smiths were never short of critical acclaim, yet the fact they are not held in the same regard as The Beatles make them the most underrated band of the past 30 years. Like The Beatles they were an unprecedented sensation, they revolutionised the pop scene and their legacy was cemented by a short-lived career and an acrimonious split. Tragedy ensured The Beatles would never reform, but as all four Smiths are alive and sober, the fans’ desire for a reunion has grown increasingly passionate over the years.

The Smiths’ story began in 1982, where Marr knocked on the reclusive Stephen Morrissey’s door and demanded the two collaborate. Five years, four albums and a thousand fights later, The Smiths’ were on the verge of a major record deal, but increasing tension between Morrissey and Marr meant a rift had appeared in the band, and everyone involved was forced to choose sides. In an effort to quell tension, Marr decided to take two-week break, however misinterpreting this, the NME published an article claiming the guitarist had officially left. This proved to be the last straw, as an emotionally exhausted Johnny Marr decided to prove the NME right and leave the band.

In 1987, few felt the split would last. Morrissey, drummer Mike Joyce and bass player Andy Rourke all begged Marr to continue, and in their later, ill-fated attempts to replace him, they made it clear they wanted The Smiths to live on. Even in the midst of his increasingly successful solo career, Morrissey continued to state in interviews that he longed for his old band. However, a reunion hinged on the irreplaceable Marr, and he held no regrets in leaving it all behind.

With Rourke and Joyce continuing to work with Morrissey on his solo records in the late 80’s, fans could still be hopeful as The Smiths needed only their prodigal guitarist to be complete, but further proving their fans are as unlucky as they are loyal, a mouldering legal conflict would soon complicate matters.

In 1996, Joyce and Rourke sued Morrissey and Marr for an equal share of The Smiths’ royalties, as up to then the rhythm section had only been receiving ten percent each. Whilst Rourke settled out of court and continued to receive ten percent, the judge ruled in favour of Joyce resulting in an equal 25% share, and £1 million in back pay.

A full four member reunion was now impossible, but even though Morrissey seemed to bear no grudges towards Johnny Marr the court case seemed to leave a foul taste in the singer’s mouth, making even a Marr/Morrissey reunion unlikely. Lawyers had now picked the legacy of The Smiths apart, the magic was gone and for Morrissey this had essentially driven the final nail in the coffin. The ever-quotable front man summarised his position perfectly when he stated, “The Smiths were a beautiful thing. Johnny left it, and Mike destroyed it.”

In the thirteen years since the royalties ruling, Marr and Morrissey have grown stronger in their resolve to leave The Smiths be. Whilst it would be easy to see this as a matter of pride; neither one wishing to concede that they’ve never lived up to the precedent of The Smiths, it’s ridiculous to suggest that their egos alone are preventing a reunion. The sad truth behind many band reunions is that a string of shows or even a new album provide an instant pension for a group’s down and out members, but Mozzer and Marr are both secure and fairly prominent on the music scene and appear to feel a Smiths re-hash would be an artistically bereft endeavour. Perhaps they’re right, but where this band is concerned you truly never know, and if it ever does happen, I wouldn’t miss it for the world.

One Foot in the Grave by Beck

When alternative icon Beck signed his first major record deal in 1994, he retained the freedom to release his previous recordings on independent labels. The result was two albums released alongside his Geffen debut Mellow Gold. The first, Stereopathetic Soulmanure was a psychedelic work almost as bizarre as its title and the second, One Foot in the Grave was a folksy yet delightfully weird summation of Beck’s acoustic beginnings. Whilst the former was at best a patchy listen, One Foot in the Grave remains to this day a scintillating insight into the Beck that was and might have been.

Of course, any self respecting Beck fan will be quick to point out that he soon returned to his acoustic roots on the Nigel Godrich produced albums Mutations and Sea Change. Yet the rugged beauty of this release has never been recaptured amongst the studio gloss of subsequent acoustic albums. The charm of One Foot in the Grave is in essence its simplicity, the spacey bleakness of ‘See Water’ or the warmth of ‘Hollow Log’ is captured perfectly in the lo-fi production, as mumbled vocals and musical mistakes contribute wonderfully to the pervading sense of authenticity and earthiness which is associated with the blues and folk artists he emulates.

Lyrically it’s often bemusing, musically it’s often discordant, yet almost by accident, the confused and ambiguous nature of the songs creates a solitary, otherworldly tone unlike anything on any other Beck record. Whilst it’s largely dismissed as a mere compilation of Beck’s experiments before he found his true sound, One Foot in the Grave is in fact a fleeting glance at a Beck who could be lonely and thoughtful without sacrificing his peculiarity. A diamond in the rough.

A musical review of my progress

Whilst this may not be a review, or even vaguely music related, it is a piece i wrote which is now on a microsite on The Times' site. Thanks a lot to Nathalie Rothschild from the Young Journalists' Academy for letting me do this:

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/global/article6618385.ece

Are You In? by De La Soul

Whilst one could never accuse De La Soul of yielding to commercialism, the last few years has seen the seminal Hip-Hop trio in pursuit of greater recognition and a larger audience. Their last full length release, 2004’s The Grind Date, was a straight up, twelve track, Hip-Hop record (a far cry from their revolutionary 24 track debut) and their collaboration with Gorillaz on the massively successful ‘Feel Good Inc.’, saw them in a place they hadn’t visited for decades, the top of the singles charts. Now, as a part of Nike’s ‘Original Run’ promotion, the Long Island pioneers have released Are You In?, a 45 minute continuous mix intended as a workout soundtrack for runners. Yet, whilst such a project screams “Sell-out”, the ever unpredictable De La Soul have subverted the allure of convention, and created some of their most inspired music in years.

Although it is labelled a ‘continuous mix’ the liner notes distinguish the ten songs which have been blended together. Designed to accompany the different stages of a run, the album begins with the laid back wake up tracks ‘Mornin Rise’ and ‘Good Mornin’. Here, the combination of Posdnuos and Dave’s expertly delivered rhymes and Flosstradamus and Young RJ’s Electronica enthused production, make these tracks easily two of the best De La have released in the past decade.

After its mellow beginnings the album shifts into its more intensive, fast paced stages, and whilst a certain level of monotony dogs such tracks as ‘Big Mouf’, the genre fusion which takes place is a continual and pleasant surprise. Such diversions as ‘Pick Up The Pace (Run)’ (a song which wanders between Rage Against The Machine-esque rock-rap and warm Jazz doodling) prove to be experiments which pay off. Whilst it may be on different terms, the group’s ability to move bodies remains evident.

With the final track, the soulful ‘Forever’ a sense of unity prevails. Whilst the album’s athletic premise may have seemed at first far too menial for such skilled veterans, it provides a structure which the band take full advantage of, as they communicate their messages and statements through their sporting demographic. On the penultimate song ‘Victory Laps’ De La address their place in Hip-Hop and their detractors through an extended athletic metaphor, creating an effortless synthesis between subject and style.

Are You In? undoubtedly has some beautiful moments, yet the album’s biggest merit is its ability to be both a unique take on the workout record, and a worthy addition to De La Soul’s canon. For the runner, this album provides a fittingly energetic athletic soundtrack, with an unexpected injection of soul and intelligence. Whilst for the De La fan, the album showcases some of the band’s most inspired and adventurous excursions to date. An against the odds return to form.